Newspaper Archive of
Heritage Florida Jewish News
Fern Park , Florida
June 5, 2009     Heritage Florida Jewish News
PAGE 17     (17 of 20 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
PAGE 17     (17 of 20 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
June 5, 2009

Newspaper Archive of Heritage Florida Jewish News produced by SmallTownPapers, Inc.
Website © 2019. All content copyrighted. Copyright Information.     Terms Of Use.     Request Content Removal.

HERITAGE FLORIDA JEWISH NEWS, JUNE 5, 2009 PAGE 17A By Tamar Snyder New York Jewish Week NEW YOI~K -In an expan- sive room at Auburn Theo- logical Seminary on 121st Street in Upper Manhattan, a diverse group of Jewish and Protestant seminarians are munching on kosher food and discussing Just War Theory, a doctrine that outlines the moral justifications and pre- requisites for waging war. They are seated in two small circles of eight students each, a mixture of both faiths, and their attention is focused on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. "Judaism hasn't had to ask these questions [about waging war as a Jewish state] for the last 2.000 years, until the sovereign state of Israel was established," says a Jew- ish student. "This is all new." "When was the last time a Protestant army or country waged a war as a Protestant country?" another Jewish student asks. The Protestant students look at each other, seriously considering the question. "Well, look at Northern Ire- land and the battles between the Protestants and the Catholics," a Protestant stu- dent replies. "Are there church authorities who offer ethical guidance?" a Jewish student asks. "The Church can't actu- ally wage war," a Protestant student replies. The Jewish student consid- ers the response. "So, if the Church can't wage war, how can it be critical of the Jews?" Conversations like these during the five meetings of the Protestant-Jewish Seminarian Dialogue groupbelieved to be the first of its kind for rab- bis and ministers-to-be -- are laying the groundwork for the more difficult discussions yet to come regarding Israeli settle- ments, the Palestinian plight and other hot-button issues. Things heat up next month, when the group of 16 future rabbis and ministers embarks on a 10-day pilgrimage to the Holy Land. Together they'll travel to Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza, where they'll experience the holy sites from the perspective of the "other." perhaps for the first time. "Auburn's core mission is to build leaders who have the capacity and understanding of the 'religious other' to reach across lines of religious dif- ference." says Rev. Katharine Rhodes Henderson, the in- coming president of Auburn Theological Seminary and a longtime proponent of multi- faith dialogue. The program, sponsored by Auburn and the New York Chapter of the American Jewish Committee, is an out- growth of the Presbyterian- Jewish conversations that began in 2004, when the Pres- byterian Church proposed that it divest from companies doing business with Israel. such as Motorola and Cater- pillar. "We wanted to bring a clearer understandingamong the Presbyterians of the pain and fear this move engendered in the Jewish community," says Diane Steinman. director of the New York chapter of the American Jewish Committee. "At the same time,we wanted the Jews among us to under- stand what the roots of [he divestment movement were and how the Presbyterians were seeing things." An initial meeting of some 75 Protestant and Jewish lay leaders and clergy led to several broader dialogue groups dur- ing the course of the next two years. "We might have known each other socially and even shared similar political and social commitments within the American constellation," Steinman says. "But we didn't know each other as committed Presbyterians and Jews." A level of trust developed and in February 2006, the steering committee, which included Rev. Henderson and Steinman, decided to visit Israel together. At the time. Hamas had just won the election in Gaza and Olmert had been elected prime min- ister but hadn't taken office yet. "The future looked very murky," Steinman admits. The trip was profound and hope-inspiring, participants attest. "It opened up a whole new level of appreciation and understanding and patience with 'the other.'" says Rev. J.C. Austin, an associate pastor at the Madison Avenue Presby- terian Church and incoming director for the Center for Church Life at Auburn. A memory that stands out for Rev. Austin is the group's visit to Atarot, an old industrial park to the north of the Old City, near Ramallah. "It was described as the end of the world; no one comes here," he says. In fact, a dump truck ille- gally dispensed atoad of refuse while the group was there. There, in the fallow ground nobody seemed to want, a joint Arab-Israeli-owned business was working to redevelop the land. "When we came back. there was a sense of urgency not to let this be a onetime, private experience," he says. That summer, the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church did not adopt divest- ment. "We felt like we were an important part of the process, and an enormous sense of relief and gratifica- tion," says Steinman. Vet the possibility of divestment is still on the table, even if it op- erates mainly in the realm of symbolism. "The divestment conversation made a light shine on the fact that there can be a deep disconnect be- tween the narratives of haany Christians and Jews regarding the Middle East," says Ethan Felson. vice president of the ICPA. It's not just different narratives, but also different modes of communication, he says. For example, sometimes when Christians speak of "doing justice," their focus is on alleviating the suffering of the poor or weak, whereas for many Jews the termbften means "doing the right thing morally and ethically." It was Rev. Henderson's "bolt of lightning," Stein- man says, to recreate this life-changCng experience for emerging religious leaders, to teach them about the complexities on both sides of the conflict and positively impact their congregations for decades to come. It took more than two years for the Protestant-Jewish Seminarian Dialogue to be- come a reality, and those in- volved believe it's the first of its kind. Since seminary students typically aren't living off the fat of the land, the steering committee raised $140,000 to heavily sponsor the Israel trip (students pay only a $150 out-of-pocket fee). The trip to Israel is critically important, participants say. "Real dialogue takes place outside of the structured dia- logue spaces and we haven't had enough of that," says Kymberly Mcnair, a student at Union Theological Seminary. Although the issue of the settlements has come up, "the discussion has been kept, at this point, to the theoretical and abstract," says Josh Frankel, a rabbinical student at Yeshivat Chovevei Torah. "I expect that we will confront the real issues when we visit them on the ground in a couple of weeks." In fact, the group will be visiting a Jewish settlement in the West Bank as part of the itinerary, confirmed Rabbi Justus Baird, the organizer of the program and director Of the Center for Multifaith Education at Auburn Theo- logical Seminary. None of the faculty during the three learning sessions discussed the settlements directly, since the learning goals were to discuss the theological, historical and so- cial justice narratives, Rabbi Baird said. "We'll be delving into the political realities on the ground when we arriver' Right now, Mcnair says, "I've been keeping m~ mouth closed and my ears open; ! want to really understand." "While dialogue alone will not solve the problem, it is the best place to start," says Char- lene Han Powell. a Princeton Theological Seminary student. She says that discussing faith and holy texts with the Jewish seminarians has "revolution- ized the way I look at the holy texts of my faith tradition." The preliminary sessions have helped to build a level of open- nessand trust.whichwilllikely be tested in a big way when faced with conflicting facts on the ground. "We've been a bit too polite," Mcnair says. "One of the difficulties for me is not having thetime to really talk about the settlements or what 'Zionism' and'Hamas' mean to this group." At the first dialogue session, the students participated in an eye-opening "paper bag" exercise. Students were given paper and asked to write down their first thoughts upon hearing buzz words such as "'occupation," "holy land" and "Hamas." The respon*ses, which were anonymously tossed into a paper bag and then transcribed on large posters, were startling, as they expressed a wide range of meanings. The word "occu- pation" mustered up feelings of "oppression and control of people considered a threat." "lost homes, lost families, lost memories," as well as reactions such as, "Who's occupying whom" and "left- ist." "Hamas" was at once a "Palestinian political party" and"Evil, taking care of short- term needs at the expense of long-term opportunity." The exercise helps "people feel comfortable expressing what's uncomfortable to say, especially in a new group," says Lisa Anderson. Auburn's edu- cation programs associate. "It gets them talking.'After each dialogue session at Auburn, the students break into "faith- alike" groups. There, in the safety of members of their own faith, they discuss difficulties they encounter while trying to communicate across religious lines. For the Protestants, there was a sense of discon- nect from Israel, a palpable feeling that the Jewish stu- dents (one of whom served in the Israeli army) exhibited a more intense connection to the holy land. They spoke about their struggle to find their own voices during dia- logue sessions, as well as the fear of being viewed as anti- Semitic. "Not because I am anti-Semitic, but what I say may stem from ignorance," one Protestant student said. "Yeah. we need Judaism 101 and Christianity 101," a fellow Protestant student replied. "It's hard to trust each other when we don't have relation- ships outside of these issues," another Protestant student said. "We're just getting to know each other's names." Interestingly enough, the interfaith program has led to increased dialogue between diverse intra-faith groups, too. In the Christian camp, students hail from the Gen- eral Theological Seminary, Princeton Theological Semi- nary and Union Theological Seminary. More diversely represented, however, are the Jewish rabbinical schools, with rabbinical students rep- resenting Hebrew Union Col- lege, JTS, Yeshivat Chovevei Torah and--perhaps most startling--Yeshiva University. "We approached this de- cision with the ideals Rav Soloveitchik articulated in an article called 'Confrontation,' in which he clearly defined appropriate conversations from an interfaith perspec- tive," says Rabbi Kenneth Brander, dean of YU's Center for the Jewish Future, adding that Rav Soloveitchik was against theological Conversa- tion in a multi-faith setting, but in favor of establishing friends outside of the Jewish community. "The Orthodox spend too much time talking to themselves" and are often unaware or ignorant of other denominations and other faiths," says Noah Greenfield, the YU rabbinical student participating in the program. "YU and CJF have to be com- mended for trying to break that mold." The goal, Greenfield says. is not to come back from the trip m full agreement but rather to "develop friendships that can overcome and .respect disagreements." The trip to Israel will be un- like any other, even for some- one like Jonah Geffen, a JTS studentwho has been to Israel some 33 tirBes. A preliminary draftoftheitinerary indicates that the seminarians will meet a diverse group of community leaders, including Israeli Jews, both religious and secular; Israeli Arabs, Palestinians, Christians and Muslims. Students will meet with IDF soldiers, journalists, political leaders and theologians~ as well as Israeli and Palestinian human rights groups, and coexistence and pro-peace process organizations. With the help of a group called Encounter, the rabbinical stu- dents will, many for the first time, witness Palestinian life in the West Bank. They'll also have the opportunity to visit Muslim and Christian holy sites, including Bethlehem, small churches in the Galilee and holy sites in the Old City. Those planning the trip say that it's important to expose the future religious leaders to a variety of viewpoints.- The goal, as Geffen articu- lates it, is that of greater un- derstanding--"understanding of one another, of our personal faiths and of the role we see for our religious traditions in helping to change conflictsitu- ations for the best. And to see the Israel-Palestinian conflict through a different set of eyes, to grow and understand that we (whatever we believe) do not have a monopoly on truth." . There's also the hope that religious leaders can bring new perspective to the Israeli- Palestinian conflict. -"We wanted to show society that religion isn't simply fuel for fires of conflict," says Rev. Austin. "Religion provides resources to address the conflict, to find ground for peace. And that starts with understanding." Reprinted with permission from the New York Jewish Week, Affordable Elegance Is Closer Than You Think Wedding Receptions, Bar/ at Mitzvahs, Social Events Beautifull ballroom will ~ accommodate over 200 guests ii~: Menu options for every taste, newly decor~ sleeping rooms, ample parking. Whygo anywhere else? Holiday Inn Select 12125 High Tech Avenue Quadrangle Park 407-275-9000 ext. 41 ,~"',,~.. ,~ ~ ~ " .... 1301 W. MaHiand Blvd., PAVILIO N Maitland, FL 32751 dmrdestoourFriendaatTheJeudshPavillon. ~ ALF kicsns~ No. 8447: SNF 1635096 www.slm.neVSCmaitland i'i i .I j~ ! !